Saturday, 22 February 2025

What’s next for the American Society for Psychical Research?


by Tom Ruffles and James A. Conrad

 

There have been significant developments in the four years since Tom Ruffles last wrote about the gradual decline of the American Society for Psychical Research (ASPR), the New York-based nonprofit organisation with a history dating back to 1884 (not 1885 as misstated for decades by current ASPR leadership, and widely repeated elsewhere).  These developments involve what appear to be murky financial transactions which had gone unchecked by regulatory bodies, despite concerned outsiders having warned them repeatedly of the deteriorating situation.

The ASPR had once been in good financial health.  It had fully owned its townhouse headquarters in New York City since 1966, when Chester Carlson (physicist and inventor of the Xerox copying process), who had previously provided financial support for research, gave the ASPR the funds to purchase a superb building just steps from Central Park.  The beautiful five-storey building, with nine fireplaces imported from Italy, was originally constructed in 1903 as a luxury residence (‘The 1903 Strasburger House -- No. 5 West 73rd Street’).  In 1978, reaffirmed in 1990, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the entire block, including the ASPR’s lot, a Historic District.

In addition to the building, when Carlson died in 1968 he left over $1 million in stock to the ASPR's endowment fund (‘American Society for Psychical Research’).  Sustained by this financial security, the organisation possessed a high profile in psychical research.  During the last three decades, however, the position has altered drastically, with large financial deficits, the unavailability of its library and archive, the cessation of its activities, and now the loss of its headquarters building.  It is worth examining the sorry affair in detail.

 

View and location of No. 5 West 73rd Street


Mortgaged to the hilt

The 2000s and 2010s saw the gradual conversion by ASPR president Nancy Sondow of the value of the nonprofit’s prestigious building at 5 West 73rd Street in Manhattan into cash via mortgages.  According to New York City official property records, between 26 September 2002 and 30 July 2019, Sondow, acting on behalf of the organisation, signed five mortgages (property equity loans) and four mortgage consolidation agreements, using the fully-owned ASPR building and lot as collateral.  The fifth mortgage, on 30 July 2019 for $1,750,000, was concurrent with the individual loans being combined into the final mortgage consolidation agreement, by which time the unpaid principal balance owed by the ASPR was $11,750,000.  For those unfamiliar with the details, a mortgage is the part of a loan agreement that describes the property being used as collateral for the cash received by way of the loan.  The other part is a promissory note, which is referenced in the mortgage.  It sets out the interest rate and repayment schedule.  Mortgages are required to be recorded in the official property records of New York City; promissory notes are not.  The cash amount of the loan is the same on both documents.

The ASPR’s mortgage loan amounts and dates signed by Sondow are as follows (these are the dates signed, not the document dates): $1,500,000 (26 September 2002), $3,951,784.35 (21 July 2011), $2,000,000 (12 May 2014), $2,800,000 (22 May 2016), and $1,750,000 (30 July 2019), a staggering total of $12,001,784.35.  There is a satisfaction of mortgage (i.e. a document acknowledging that the terms of the mortgage agreement have been fulfilled) showing in the property records for the first mortgage because the loan was acquired by another lender and the original lender needed to state that it was no longer involved.  The mortgage came due on 29 July 2020, but the ASPR failed to pay the outstanding principal and interest on that date, thereby defaulting on the loan.

These figures have to compared with those reported to the federal Internal Revenue Service (IRS) on its annual Form 990 return.  According to the 2019 990, the mortgages totalled $10,000,000 at the start of the year and $11,750,000 at the end, reflecting the mortgage for $1,750,000 signed in July 2019.  On this, $1,097,845 in interest was paid.  It is curious that Sondow signed another mortgage in 2019 while the property was being put on the market because payments could not be met.  The mortgage amount reported to the IRS in subsequent years remained at $11,750,000 until the start of 2022, and by the end of that year was showing as $0.

Whether the ASPR’s executive director Patrice Keane had a direct role in the mortgage transactions arranged by Sondow is unknown.  Keane’s signature does not appear on any of the five mortgages signed by Sondow but her email address alone is given on mortgage number five, 30 July 2019, and on the final mortgage consolidation agreement, also 30 July 2019, which lists all the previous mortgages, as one of the contractually obligated places to send notices and requests.  The other contacts are Sondow and the ASPR’s then attorney, Jay Gerzog.  With regard to the promissory notes, it is unknown if Keane received any notices, or if her name or email address appear on any of them.  The notes are kept privately by the lender and borrower.  Since Keane was the only salaried employee, one would expect her to have been aware of the sources of her nonprofit’s income.

 

Five mortgages, 2002-2019


After the mortgages were signed the money effectively vanished, with no explanation by the ASPR leadership to the public or membership as to why the five loans were needed and what became of the money.  Unless it, or what is recoverable, reemerges at some future point, this is money lost to the mission for which the ASPR was set up.  Unfortunately, it appears that a significant portion of the borrowed money was used to pay monthly interest and is gone forever.  Eventually, with the ASPR having no funds to pay back the consolidation mortgage, the ASPR’s Manhattan headquarters building was put up for sale in July 2019 with a price tag of just under $18 million.  It failed to sell (the Covid pandemic cannot have helped), the price was reduced to $15,750,00, and it was eventually withdrawn.

There was a silver lining for the ASPR to the pandemic, however, because it received two loans from the U.S. Government under the Paycheck Protection Program (‘PPP Loan Data – American Society For Psychical Research, New York, NY’).  Provided by the Small Business Administration, one was for $26,380 in May 2020, the second for $26,382 in March 2021 – a total of $52,762.  The PPP website states that “the vast majority of businesses are expected to have the majority or all of their PPP loan forgiven by the SBA, effectively making it a grant.”   Why a significant sum of money was made available to an organisation that was moribund is a question for the Small Business Administration to answer.

 

Follow the money

The ASPR’s declining fortunes can be followed by examining its obligatory financial returns (it is registered as a non-profit under 501(c)(3) Title 26 of the United States Code, making it exempt from property taxes; according to the ProPublica website, it has been tax-exempt since September 1942).  It makes two types of financial filings.  One is Form 990, ‘Return of Organization Exempt From Income Tax’, submitted to the IRS.  The other is Form CHAR500, ‘Annual Filing for Charitable Organizations’, submitted to the New York State Office of the Attorney General Charities Bureau.  These make fascinating reading, as they allow outsiders a glimpse of developments within the organisation that would otherwise be hidden from the outside world.

Tracking back over the past half decade, the 2019 Form 990, dated 29 October 2020, shows a number of individuals as trustees, though none can be said to be particularly well-known in the field (the last person to sit on the board with a profile in parapsychology was Keith Harary, who had left by the time the 2018 Form 990 was produced).  In addition to Sondow, the board comprised George Kokoris, Barbara Gallagher, Susan Hurley, Elizabeth Maldonado and Marie Cooper Janis.  Janis is probably Maria Cooper Janis, the daughter of the actor and Hollywood legend Gary Cooper (she also goes by the name Marie).  These individuals’ names have not been publicised by the ASPR and are only known because of the requirement to file legal documents.  In addition to their positions as trustees, Sondow was listed as president, Kokoris as treasurer and second vice president, and Janis as first vice president, though these vice-presidential roles are not explained.  None of these positions was renumerated.  Keane’s salary was $139,955.

Mysteriously, a loan appears on the 2019 Form 990 Schedule L (“Transactions With Interested Persons”) from the ASPR to Nancy Sondow in the amount of $1,770,000 for the purpose of “working capital”, though working for what purpose is left unspecified.  At this point the ASPR was running a deficit of minus $12,058,585, up from minus $10,509,248 the previous year.  The 2019 Form 990 form shows Sondow as president and trustee, but the Form CHAR500 for 2019 was co-signed by Sondow as President/Treasurer and Kokoris as Treasurer; Sondow had suddenly become co-treasurer besides her role as president, though this was only temporary.

 

The loan to Nancy Sondow


On the matter of loans, it is worth noting that according to the website of the Office of the New York State Attorney General, “Charities, other than those established as education corporations, are not permitted to lend money to their officers and directors, even if they have good business reasons for wanting to make the loan” (‘Frequently Asked Questions for Charities, Non-Profits & Fundraisers’).  However, New York State law makes no mention of any exception for education corporations (‘Section 716: Loans to directors, officers and key persons’).  It might be argued that one of the purposes of the ASPR is education, and the word appears a number of times in its supporting 990 documentation, but to the question on the 990 form, “Is the organization an educational institution subject to the section 4968 excise tax on net investment income?”, the answer is “no”, and it would be hard to describe the ASPR as an education corporation.  Similarly, the online legal dictionary USLegal specifically defines an Educational Corporation as “a corporation formed not for profit but for an educational purpose, particularly the establishment and maintenance of a school, college, or university” (‘Educational Corporation Law and Legal Definition’).  Some clarity on the nature of the loan to Sondow would be welcome.  It would not be enough to state that it was authorised by the board and therefore is legitimate.

Examining the 2020 Form 990, dated 28 October 2021, Keane is listed as executive director, with a salary of $293,662, which is an increase of $100,000 on the previous year (there seems to be no rationale for her wildly fluctuating remuneration).  The loan to Sondow for working capital is now showing as $1,750,000, $20,000 having presumably been repaid.  Kokoris is shown as treasurer and Maldonado is secretary, though the latter is an unpaid honorary position with one suspects few duties.  The Form CHAR500 document for 2020, dated 16 November 2023, is signed by Sondow and Maldonado, who had taken over Kokoris’s treasurer role, though retitled chief financial officer.  There is no explanation for the delay between submitting the two documents covering 2020, and it is unclear if the delay was related to the Covid-19 pandemic.

There was a hiatus until the summer of 2024, when the APSR belatedly submitted a flurry of financial documents.  There is again no explanation why there was such a lengthy delay.  Whatever the cause, the delay may have involved significant late fees.  The Form 990 for 2021 is dated 14 June 2024, the 2021 Form CHAR500 is dated 15 July 2024.  The Form 990 shows the same set of trustees, with Keane’s salary at a relatively modest $25,300, a marked reduction from previous years and perhaps reflecting financial realities; after all, when haemorrhaging money the optics of recording a six-figure salary on official forms does tend to raise eyebrows.  Again, though, there is a loan shown against Sondow’s name of $1,750,000.  The ASPR’s total assets at the end of the year were $645,544, against total liabilities of $13,540,234, making its net assets minus $12,894,690.  The Form CHAR500 shows that Maldonado had reverted to the less pretentious title of treasurer, though on the 990 she is shown as secretary, Kokoris as treasurer.

CHAR500 forms for 2022 and 2023 do not seem to be available, but the 990s are.  The 2022 Form 990 is dated 20 October 2024.  With total revenue of $19,433,570 and expenses of $7,623,696, net assets now stand at minus $1,093,222, a reduction of $11,801,468.  Income of $18,887,361 (up from $11,524 the preceding year) is allegedly derived from investments, though mysteriously there is no investment detailed.  The eye-watering figure for expenses is largely made up of $7,115,526 in interest payments.  Interest was due on the loan until the property was sold, and would be compounded if no payments were made.  Interest payment in 2020 according to the Form 990 is $158,081, which confirms an inability to service the debt.  The $7,115,526 shown in the 2022 Form 990 return could easily be accrued given the annual interest rate of 15% on the original principal of $11,750,000, plus 10% on late fees.  A $1,750,000 loan for working capital is still shown against Sondow’s name.  Keane’s salary is $88,585, a marked increase on the previous year but nowhere near its historic highs.  As an aside, Keane’s consistently high salary over many years makes her by far the best-paid individual in psychical research.

Where the money might have come from in 2022 to reduce the deficit so significantly is unknown.  No satisfaction (i.e. repayment) of the consolidation mortgage was ever recorded, although this mortgage has disappeared from the ASPR’s balance sheet on the 2022 Form 990 return.  At this point, only the ASPR board, or a forensic accountant with legal access, can shed light on the matter.

The paper trail in this story winds to a close – for now – with the 2023 Form 990, dated 15 November 2024.  Astonishingly, it shows a positive balance, with assets of $2,631,595, a change from the previous year’s minus $1,093,222.  There is no explanation for the injection of cash on this form.  It must be stressed that this is not because of the repayment of the mortgage.  Reflecting the favourable environment, Keane’s salary has more than doubled since the previous year to $199,000.  Sondow’s working capital seems to have finally started working, as the original principal amount of $1,750,000 now shows a balance of $825,000.  While total revenue amounts to $4,165,122, a figure which is not explained, expenses are $467,709, a fraction of the preceding year’s but still substantial.  Perhaps reflecting this increased financial activity, Maldono is joint treasurer with Kokoris, in addition to her role as secretary.  Encouragingly, the supplemental information on the Form 990, carried from year to year, still asserts that:

“The ASPR holds a vast archive of documents, photographs, drawings, rare manuscripts, reports of experiences, research data, correspondence, and books that date back to the 1600s ... The ASPR continues to seek out, collect, preserve, protect, duplicate, digitize, and organize these important research documents for its library and archives.”

There had been considerable expenditure on “rents/storage fees” since 2019, amounting to $21,115 that year, $23,940 in 2020, and $29,042 in 2021.  There was a leap to $47,022 in 2022 and $58,250 in 2023.  This significant amount indicates the extensive archive is still intact, though perhaps is not being expanded to the extent the statement suggests.  If items are being digitised, it is in secret.  That the archive is in storage rather than readily accessible is an unsatisfactory state of affairs, and the level of expenditure is probably unsustainable, throwing its long-term future into doubt.  The storage location and fitness for the purpose are unknown, except to insiders.

 

The unfolding of a scandal

The gradual fall-off and finally cessation of any visible activities and associated financial manoeuvres were for a long time little noticed by those outside the ASPR.  There was no regular programme of lectures or conferences or systematic public communication.  The Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research, first published in 1907, ceased in 2004, as is stated on the page devoted to the Journal on the ASPR website (the ASPR also published Proceedings on an irregular basis from 1885, but as of this writing it does not merit a page on the website.  The most recent volume on the shelves of the Society for Psychical Research in London is dated 1974, which appears to be the last issued).  This inactivity regarding the Journal should have been a red flag that something was amiss within the organisation.

Despite the obvious decrease in member benefits and public engagement, surprisingly there was a general lack of interest among American parapsychologists, including ex-ASPR members.  More recently, there has been a reluctance to become involved in a campaign to save it, particularly its historically significant archive.  To their shame, board members gradually dropped out and remained silent rather than defend the organisation.  Even when it became clear what was happening with the finances, eminent figures in the field were willing to deplore the situation privately but not act publicly.  Until recently, criticism of the ASPR management was sporadic, the general attitude one of apathy. 

That the situation which is now so painfully evident is not of recent origin is evidenced by Robert McConnell’s expression of disquiet as long ago as 1995 (Far Out in the New Age), and George Hansen’s in 2007 (‘A Salary in Parapsychology: Patrice Keane (ASPR)’), and again in 2012 at that year’s Academy of Spirituality and Paranormal Studies conference.  Hansen noted the scale of the salary paid to Keane, a six-figure sum for activities invisible to the outside, while the Society’s assets were drained.  In 2011 Stacy Horn recounted her frustrations attempting to gain access to the ASPR’s archive (‘What is the deal with the ASPR?’), Guy Lyon Playfair published an article in Fortean Times (‘An American Institution in Low Spirits’) in 2014, and in 2019 Ruffles began to document the saga.

A brief two-part TikTok video, ‘What happened to the American Society for Psychical Research?’ was posted by the GeoHaunts account in 2021.  The first part notes that the ASPR has not opened its doors since 2018 and asks what has happened to the library; the second points out that with their charitable status uncertain, they are still accepting donations, and it includes a note, an opinion by GeoHaunts, stating, “Charity fraud: soliciting donations for an organisation that does little or no work.”  The ASPR certainly does no discernible work and its very dated website as of this writing continues to solicit donations, so the implication is clear.  Sadly, GeoHaunts’ effort has so far gained little traction.

Complaints by a small number of individuals who were appalled at what was happening have been sent to the New York Charities Bureau since 2019, urging it to investigate what was possibly the serious offences of embezzlement and money laundering (no counter-explanation for the disposal of the funds being forthcoming).  Jay Gerzog, the attorney for the ASPR who is listed on the 2019 mortgage consolidation agreement, was notified of the controversy via email by James A. Conrad on 21 September 2020, and a copy was forwarded to the New York Charities Bureau on 23 September, but neither responded.  It included the information that there was a five-year statute of limitations for grand larceny and money laundering, and, based on the publicly recorded date of the loan consolidation, it was due, in Conrad’s view, to expire on 30 July 2024.  Regular follow-up emails to the Charities Bureau were ignored.  These emails urged the intervention of New York Attorney General Letitia James and Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, because if there had been malfeasance time was short.  The Charities Bureau is run by the New York Attorney General’s Office, of which Letitia James is currently in charge.

Someone who wrote to the Charities Bureau in 2023 did receive a reply, which was passed to us.  It appears mostly to be a standard response which says that due to the high volume of complaints and limited resources it is not possible to investigate every allegation.  It continues that the Bureau will scrutinise this particular complaint to see if there are grounds for action by the Attorney General, adding: “In addition, we will contact American Society for Psychical Research to request that it remedy its delinquency in filing annual reports with the Charities Bureau.”  While the letter acknowledged there were governance issues, there was no follow-up correspondence.  It is possible that prompting by the Charities Bureau was a factor in the ASPR submitting the outstanding financial returns, though it still took a year for them to act.  At least this correspondent received prompter treatment than Conrad’s efforts to highlight the matter did.

The eleventh email sent to the Charities Bureau by Conrad, on 31 July 2024, noting the ostensible expiry of the statute of limitations, finally elicited a reply the same day in an attached PDF letter, also dated 31 July.  It does not say why no reply had been made to Conrad’s earlier emails.  Again, it appears mostly to be a standard response, claiming that due to the high volume of complaints and limited resources it is not possible to investigate every allegation.  It does not say whether the ASPR will be one of them, only that Conrad’s correspondence will be evaluated.  This is precisely the same boilerplate text as contained in the reply sent to the letter writer the previous year.

As part of the standard text, the letter contains the following caveat: “The complaint you have filed with this Office has no effect on any statute of limitations filing deadlines that might apply to your claim.”  As there has not been a follow-up from them, or any public announcement regarding the ASPR, presumably the Charities Bureau and New York Attorney General Letitia James are still pondering whether to act.  Possibly they calculate the time limits differently, or there are other applicable laws at the state or federal level involving information on tax returns and banking transactions that apply to longer or unlimited investigation deadlines.

 

Charities Bureau letter to James A. Conrad


In addition to direct approaches to the Charities Bureau, Conrad contacted several news media outlets and journalists, including those actively seeking tip-offs, one of whom claimed to specialise in alleged wrongdoing at non-profits.  There were several vague expressions of interest, but none translated into articles.  He also emailed Nicholas J. Little, Legal Director for the New York State-based nonprofit The Center for Inquiry on 20 July 2021 and invited CFI to join the effort in asking the Charities Bureau to investigate, but did not receive a reply.  A petition set up on Change.org in 2019 by a concerned member of the public (neither of the present authors initiated it) has over 600 signers as of this writing but has yet to bring the scandal to wider public attention (‘Save the American Society for Psychical Research!’).

One person who might have been in a position to use his high profile to generate interest in the situation is Dan Aykroyd, who on a number of occasions has cited the influence reading the ASPR Journal had on him when he was developing the script for the 1984 film Ghostbusters, his father having been a subscriber and the movie's story being set in New York City.  He himself was a member (‘No laughing matter’), and in May 2009 chose the ASPR building as the venue for an interview with Seth Schiesel of the New York Times, tied in with the release of a new Ghostbusters game by Atari.  The article describes the building as “one of his favourite places.” (‘New Video Game? Who You Gonna Call?’).  So far, Aykroyd has not added his voice to those who are asking what is happening to the organisation.

Another who has not put his weight publicly behind calls to save the ASPR is novelist Grady Hendrix.  He once worked at the ASPR where, “besides archiving letters, case studies, drawings, and photographs, Hendrix handled the ASPR’s phone line, taking requests for help from researchers and regular people alike.” (‘Grady Hendrix is a comic writer with a thing for horror’).  In November 2024 he was still referring to his time at the ASPR during a book tour (‘This horror writer’s most outlandish character is himself’).  Ruffles wrote to Hendrix via his website email address on 1 July 2020, asking if he had any inside information about the ASPR’s decline, and hoping he might help to publicise the situation.  On 11 November 2024, James A. Conrad invited him on X to email the New York Charities Bureau and ask for an update on their investigation (on the assumption there was one).  Hendrix did not acknowledge either approach.

 

The ASPR headquarters is sold

The Society’s final interaction with the media seems to have been in October 2017, when Keane gave journalist Liz Hardaway a tour of the building for the Our Town website (‘The Psychics of Chelsea’) and mentioned the ASPR was seeking funding for an exhibition on spirit photography, which has yet to materialise.  The article was reproduced on Hardaway’s website, and her two photographs of the inside of the building show the archive was still present at that time.  When contacted by Conrad in a 21 February 2022 email to learn if she or any colleagues might be interested in doing a follow-up story on the current status of the ASPR, she did not reply.

Photographs on real estate websites in 2019 show that some of the books were still in situ as a feature, but the interior had been transformed into a luxurious residence with a white theme to the decor (e.g. ‘$18M Beaux-Arts mansion is an Upper West Side architectural icon with Dakota views’).  By the beginning of 2023, the premises had been completely cleared (‘NYC townhouse and occult researchers’ headquarters lists for $15M’).

The WebCivil Supreme website is a government-operated repository of documents for the New York State Civil Supreme Courts, and it provides valuable information charting the course of the ASPR’s loss of its building.  A foreclosure lawsuit against the ASPR headquarters was filed in the New York State Supreme Court on 11 February 2021, a process that occurs after missed mortgage payments.  The lawsuit named the ASPR and John Does 1-5, a legal tactic that allows naming defendants in the future, for example, if Sondow and Keane became unavailable as the lawsuit progressed through the court system.  As we have seen, the foreclosure lawsuit stated the consolidated loan note had an interest rate of 15% annually and 10% interest on late fees.

 

The lawsuit


The ASPR initially offered a defence to the lawsuit, but later withdrew it, and the judge granted a motion by the lender (Plaintiff) for the court to appoint a trusted individual called a Receiver to take operational management and financial oversight of the property in May 2022.  At this point the ASPR lost physical control of the building (but not legal ownership), as the Receiver would be responsible for preserving the property, subsequent financial transactions, and settling the debt, returning any remaining balance to the organisation.  A “vacancy deadline”, for the building to be vacated, was set at 11.59 pm (New York time) on 19 September, 2022, although this was amenable to modification by mutual agreement between Plaintiff and Defendant.

A “Stipulation of Settlement” was filed on 17 June, 2022.  This was an agreement between the Plaintiff, 73 LLC (i.e. limited liability company), which held the mortgage on 5 West 73rd Street, formerly the ASPR’s headquarters, and the ASPR plus John Does 1-5.  There are two key points to draw from this document.  The first is that the Plaintiff agreed that the outcome of the foreclosure sale would be the limit of their complaint against the ASPR, and that they would not pursue the organisation or any of the John Does for further funds if the auction failed to recover all of the monies owed, including the interest accrued to date.  Secondly, presumably as a result this undertaking, the ASPR withdrew their answer (i.e. defence) to the initial Complaint lodged by the Plaintiff, meaning the judgement was uncontested.

In a judgement filed on 24 June, 2022, the Hon. Francis Kahn III ordered the building and lot to be sold at a public auction.  The Referee was ordered to pay the Plaintiff the amount due, a sum of $18,865,223.63 with, from 13 May, 2022 to the sale, the punitive per diem interest rate of 24% added.  This document confirms that the Plaintiff’s complaint against the ASPR, i.e. the non-payment of the consolidated mortgage principal of $11,750,00, had grown to over $18 million with interest.  The 2022 Form 990 shows the $11,750,000 mortgage was no longer on the balance sheet at the end of the year.

 

eCourt auction notice


A “Notice of sale” was filed with the New York County Clerk on 30 December 2022 by Thomas Kleinberger as the Referee, and Glenn Rodney, attorney for the Plaintiff.  It stated that the “approximate amount of judgment is $18,865,223.63 plus interest and costs.”  There was a last-ditch attempt to sell the property in January 2023, because it was put back on the market for $15 million, as reported in the New York Post (‘NYC townhouse and occult researchers’ headquarters lists for $15M’).  The offering expired on the date of the auction.  This was not the act of the Receiver, because a foreclosure lawsuit in New York only allows the court to auction the property to pay the debt, not to sell it, rather it was a desperate attempt by Sondow and Keane to avoid the auction, though it was unlikely to succeed given the timescale and would still have left the ASPR well short of the total owed (perhaps the hope was that with the publicity generated by the New York Post article there would be a bidding war to increase the sale price).  The effort failed anyway, and the foreclosure auction went ahead as scheduled.

The auction took place on 1 February, 2023, with an outcome of “Sold”.  Interestingly, a “Receiver’s Deed” wasn’t signed and recorded in the official property records until June 2024; it is not known why the parties waited sixteen months before creating the new mortgage documents with the buyer and recording the deed.  A “Foreclosure Action Surplus Monies Form” was filed with the court on 8 January, 2025 and shows that there was no surplus money from the 2023 auction turned over to the ASPR.  It had been signed on 20 June, 2024 by the representative for 73 Servicing, LLC.  The considerable length of time between the sale date and making the information public is again puzzling: the form itself states: “To be completed for every sale by court appointed Referee and filed with County Clerk and the Supreme Court Calendar Clerk within 30 days of sale.”

 

eCourt document list


Under new Ownership

In June 2024, the website traded announced the sale of the building to Walter Baker (‘Walter Baker Acquires Specialty Building From American Society For Psychical Research For $11.75M’).  This was much lower than it had been on the market for previously, and less than the ASPR’s liabilities.  The summary continues: “Walter Baker, represented by 5w73rd LLC, acquired the specialty building in a foreclosure sale from the American Society for Psychical Research, marking a significant transaction in the market.”  Devastating more accurately sums up this sale for those engaged in psychical research.  The PropertyShark website, containing information about the building, includes the question “When was 5 West 73rd Street, New York, NY 10023 last sold and what was the last sale price?”, to which the answer is: “5 West 73rd Street, New York, NY 10023 was last sold in [sic] 06/25/2024 for $100” (‘5 West 73rd Street, New York, NY 10023 Property Information’).  The payment of this nominal amount served to seal the deal.

Baker has a LinkedIn profile in which he describes himself thus: “I’m a Real Estate Buyer Agent with years of experience as a seasoned buyer liaison to the art and design, luxury industry.  I have a passion for interiors, design and furnishings.  I consider it an honor to be searching, viewing and acting on behalf of my clients as we go through the buying process together.”  According to his LinkedIn profile he has been employed as a real estate buyer agent for LG Fairmont since 2017, but he is not listed on their website, so is presumably now working on his own.  To clarify the situation, on 20 December 2024 Ruffles reached out (to use the popular expression) to LG Fairmont asking to be put in touch with Mr Baker.  They did not reply.

The new owner of the former ASPR headquarters building and lot, as listed on the New York City Department of Finance website (the Parcel Identifier is Manhattan, Block 1126, Lot 127), is 5w73rd LLC.  Presumably Baker, through 5w73rd LLC, which, as it shares its name with the old ASPR building’s address would have been set up to acquire the property, is either going to develop it and sell it on, or is acting as a representative for an unknown buyer who wishes to remain anonymous.  One wonders if the new owner and any others involved in the purchase realise how controversial the acquisition is.

The image of the New York building only disappeared from the ASPR website some time after mid-January 2025, a delay a cynic might have considered a case of false representation.  The address given on the website for individuals who wish to join by post, or make a donation, is now 459 Columbus Avenue #714, New York, NY 10024, which was the first obvious alteration to the website for a long time.  This is a rented mailbox at Manhattan Express Shipping, on the west side near Central Park, evidence the ASPR no longer has a physical office, just a virtual one.  At the time of writing, the ASPR website’s “Join the Society” page still carries a range of membership levels, from $70 for associates to $50,000 plus for benefactors.  Associates, it says, “receive discounts to talks, conferences, and special events, and may use the library by appointment.”  If the organisation is still soliciting membership fees but not providing the advertised benefits or explaining why they are unavailable, that must be considered fraud.

To try to clarify the situation, Ruffles made a number of requests for information to the ASPR.  On 14 December 2024 he sent the following to the general ASPR email address on its website (aspr@aspr.com): “I note that your New York headquarters has now been sold.  Will you be making a statement about the financial aspects of this transaction, and tell those interested (of which I am one) about the current whereabouts of the organisation’s library and archive?  What plans do you have to continue the ASPR?”

A more detailed set of questions was sent on 10 January 2025 to secretary Elizabeth Maldonado covering a number of issues, notably the building sale, the mortgages and the archive, concluding: “In sum, do the current trustees intend to restore the Society to a full membership organisation which fulfills the objectives for which it was founded?  If that is not the trustees’ vision, can you tell me what it is?”  The following day similar emails were sent to the email addresses of Nancy Sondow and Patrice Keane, as found on official documents.  None responded.

 

ASPR on YouTube!

Somewhat to our surprise, on the last day of 2024 a YouTube channel, “ASPR Inc.,” uploaded three videos.  The channel was set up by the ASPR (there is a link to it on the ASPR website) on 16 February 2024, but had hitherto been inactive.  The first video is a clip taken from Powers of the Mind, the first programme in a three-part 1992 BBC documentary In Search of the Dead, which features Sondow.  The other two are talks given by her which are copyrighted 2017 and 2018 by the ASPR.  Comments have been turned off on all three videos.  The “About” section contains the sentence “Through its lectures, archives and information services the ASPR addresses important questions,” and refers to its “mission”, as if these activities are ongoing.  The obvious question why for all practical purposes a defunct organisation would go to the trouble of uploading videos could be to give the impression it is still active, even though there is little effort involved in putting old videos on YouTube.  At the time of writing, the number of subscribers has just reached double figures.  There is also a Facebook page in the name of the ASPR, with 137 followers at the time of writing, which is merely a placeholder with no content.

 

What now?

For the moment it looks like the ASPR has been saved from total collapse, but whether it can be restored as a viable concern that will once more make important contributions to psychical research is another matter.  Currently using a rented mailbox, it is difficult to see how it can operate without a proper office, despite Keane still claiming to work an average 60 hour week according to the 2023 Form 990.  No public communications have been made by the president, executive director or the trustees.  The ASPR currently has no active social media accounts.

There are two separate issues to consider, now that the nonprofit’s headquarters building has been sold.  Firstly, can any illegal actions be laid at the door of ASPR officers, with guilty parties brought to account?  Related to this point, if any money has been extracted illicitly from the Society can it be recovered, and, if it is, how can it be safeguarded and used for the purpose for which the organisation was founded?

Secondly, the whereabouts of the archive and library should be established, its integrity as a collection respected, and if the ASPR is unable to manage it, a suitable home found so that once again it is made available to researchers.  Eyes are watching to see if items turn up for sale on the open market in case there is an attempt to dispose of its contents.  A further worry is the possibility that if rental fees go unpaid for a commercial storage space the contents may be auctioned off to the highest bidder.  This situation should be a concern of anyone who has a regard for the subject.

If it proves impossible to resurrect the ASPR as more than an entity which only exists on paper and a website, and its leaders are found wanting, observers have suggested that any funds might be transferred to another organisation in the same field, such as the Parapsychology Foundation (PF), similarly a New York-based non-profit.  The PF provides an excellent example of an organisation which sought to ensure the survival of its heritage, rather than see it as a disposable asset.  Encountering severe financial pressures and a lack of external funding, the Foundation faced the breakup of its historically important Garrett Research Library.

Rather than sell it, however, the PF made the ethical decision to donate it to the Special collections of the Albin O. Kuhn Library of the University of Maryland Baltimore County.  Announcing the donation, PF president Lisette Coly stated that “Leaving such a carefully crafted resource for future students of the paranormal was of overall greater import than the life of a non-profit organization.” (‘Heartbroken’).  The PF’s board of trustees stand in contrast to those individuals who have charge of the ASPR.

Nancy Sondow and Patrice Keane have had an iron grip on the ASPR for over thirty years:  Keane has been executive director since 1992, Sondow has been president since 1993.  Now is clearly the time for change.  If they truly have its interests at heart, they and the trustees will make a public statement outlining the current situation, their plans for the future (including the acquisition of new premises), the reinstatement of a membership base as outlined on the website, and setting out a timetable for democratic elections to the positions of trustees.  It is only with a fresh start that the ASPR will once again become a significant force in psychical research, but anyone contemplating joining, or rejoining, will want to have confidence that its leaders have members’ interests at heart, and not their own.  Failing these actions, it should seek to merge with another existing nonprofit organisation.

Those wishing to express their dissatisfaction with the present state of affairs can contact the New York Charities Bureau at charities.bureau@ag.ny.gov.  The Change.org petition still has some way to go to reach its target of 1,000 signatures, so anyone who has yet to sign it is urged to do so.  If anyone has had any kind of communication from the ASPR recently, or has further information about the situation, please feel free to email tom.ruffles@yahoo.co.uk.  Finally, it would be heartening if those active in the field and in the news media stopped sitting on their hands and helped to bring this scandal to the public’s attention.

 

Note: Those wishing to examine the 990 and CR500 financial filings, property records, and foreclosure court records for themselves may do so here (forensic accountants particularly welcome):

New York State Office of the Attorney General: https://www.charitiesnys.com/RegistrySearch/show_details.jsp?id={10CB3494-0000-C014-BC12-3FDE9A9F4923}

Propublica: https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/131655205

New York City property records (Borough of Manhattan, Block 1126, Lot 127): https://a836-acris.nyc.gov/CP/

WebCivil Supreme, the New York State eCourts database (Case Index No. 850211/2020): https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/webcivil/FCASMain

 

The information in this article was sourced from public records and other publicly available sources and is believed to be accurate to the best of the authors’ knowledge and belief. 

The ASPR, along with its current president Nancy Sondow, executive director Patrice Keane, and secretary/co-treasurer Elizabeth Maldonado, were contacted by email individually and given the opportunity to respond to questions.  No reply has been received from any of them after more than a month of waiting.  We will update this post in the event one is received.

 

References

‘5 West 73rd Street, New York, NY 10023 Property Information’, PropertyShark, https://www.propertyshark.com/mason/Property/17384/5-W-73-St-New-York-NY-10023/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

American Society for Psychical Research website, http://www.aspr.com/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

‘American Society for Psychical Research’, The Psi Encyclopedia, created 10 September 2019, https://psi-encyclopedia.spr.ac.uk/articles/american-society-psychical-research (accessed 12 February 2025).

Andrews, Travis M., ‘This horror writer’s most outlandish character is himself’, The Washington Post, 12 January 2025, https://www.washingtonpost.com/books/2025/01/12/grady-hendrix-witchcraft-wayward-girls/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

Cohen, Michelle, ‘$18M Beaux-Arts mansion is an Upper West Side architectural icon with Dakota views’, 6sqft, 12 July 2019, https://www.6sqft.com/18m-beaux-arts-mansion-is-an-upper-west-side-architectural-icon-with-dakota-views/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

Coly, Lisette, ‘Heartbroken’, Parapsychology Foundation, Inc., 18 September 2023, https://parapsychology.org/heartbroken/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

‘Educational Corporation Law and Legal Definition’, USLegal, https://definitions.uslegal.com/e/educational-corporation/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

Frishberg, Hannah, ‘NYC townhouse and occult researchers’ headquarters lists for $15M’, New York Post, 17 January 2023, https://nypost.com/2023/01/17/nyc-home-and-occult-researchers-headquarters-lists-for-15m/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

GeoHaunts, ‘American Society for Psychical Research - What Happened?’ Part 1, TikTok, 16 August 2021, https://www.tiktok.com/@geohaunts/video/6997162251295657221?lang=en (accessed 12 February 2025).

GeoHaunts, ‘American Society for Psychical Research’ Part 2, TikTok, 29 August 2021, https://www.tiktok.com/@geohaunts/video/7001672903993462021?lang=en (accessed 12 February 2025).

Hardaway, Liz, ‘The Psychics of Chelsea’, Our Town, 17 October 2017, https://www.otdowntown.com/news/local-news/the-psychics-of-chelsea-EDNP1220171017171019941 (accessed 12 February 2025).

‘Goodsort, T. C.’, ‘Save the American Society for Psychical Research!’, Change.org, 5 November 2019, https://www.change.org/p/new-york-charities-bureau-save-the-american-society-for-psychical-research (accessed 12 February 2025).

Hansen, George P., ‘A Salary in Parapsychology: Patrice Keane (ASPR)’, 13 August 2007, http://paranormaltrickster.blogspot.co.uk/2007/08/salary-in-parapsychology-patrice-keane.html (accessed 12 February 2025).

Hansen, George P., ‘Panel – Psience: What New Developments in Scientific Investigation Promote Understanding of Psi?’ Academy of Spirituality and Paranormal Studies, Inc, Annual Conference Proceedings, 2012.

Horn, Stacy, ‘What is the deal with the ASPR?’, 20 November 2011, http://www.echonyc.com/~horn/unbelievable/?p=2412 (accessed 12 February 2025).

Krasnow, Iris, ‘No laughing matter’, UPI, 28 May 1984, https://www.upi.com/Archives/1984/05/28/NO-LAUGHING-MATTER/6806454564800/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

Miller, Tom, ‘The 1903 Strasburger House - No. 5 West 73rd Street’, 12 January 2013, https://daytoninmanhattan.blogspot.com/2013/01/the-1903-strasburger-house-no-5-west.html (accessed 12 February 2025).

New York State Attorney General (Letitia James), ‘Frequently Asked Questions for Charities, Non-Profits & Fundraisers’, https://ag.ny.gov/resources/organizations/charities-non-profits-fundraisers/charities-non-profits-fundraisers-faqs (accessed 12 February 2025).

Pandolfi, Elizabeth, ‘Grady Hendrix is a comic writer with a thing for horror’, Charleston City Paper, 19 November 2014, https://charlestoncitypaper.com/2014/11/19/grady-hendrix-is-a-comic-writer-with-a-thing-for-horror/ (accessed 12 February 2025).

Playfair, Guy Lyon, ‘An American Institution in Low Spirits’, Fortean Times, Issue 320, November 2014, pp. 52-3.

‘PPP Loan Data — American Society For Psychical Research, New York, NY’, FederalPay.org, https://www.federalpay.org/paycheck-protection-program/american-society-for-psychical-research-new-york-ny (accessed 12 February 2025).

Ruffles, Tom, ‘More Downs than Ups at the American Society for Psychical Research’, 18 July 2019, https://tomruffles.blogspot.com/2019/07/more-downs-than-ups-at-american-society.html.

Ruffles, Tom, review of McConnell, Robert, Far Out in the New Age: The Subversion of Science by Cultural Communism, a Compendium of Current Social Controversy (self-published, 1995), 11 November 2019, https://tomruffles.wordpress.com/2019/11/11/far-out-in-the-new-age-by-robert-mcconnell/.

Ruffles, Tom, ‘The American Society for Psychical Research: Recent Developments’, 20 February 2020, https://tomruffles.blogspot.com/2020/02/the-american-society-for-psychical.html.

Ruffles, Tom, ‘The American Society for Psychical Research: Action Required’, 3 April 2020, https://tomruffles.blogspot.com/2020/04/the-american-society-for-psychical.html.

‘Section 716: Loans to directors, officers and key persons’, The New York State Senate, https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/NPC/716 (accessed 12 February 2025).

Schiesel, Seth, ‘New Video Game? Who You Gonna Call?’, New York Times, 28 May 2009, https://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/31/arts/31schi.html (accessed 12 February 2025).

‘Walter Baker Acquires Specialty Building From American Society For Psychical Research For $11.75M’, traded, https://traded.co/deals/new-york/special-purpose/sale/5-west-73rd-street/ (accessed 12 February 2025).


Wednesday, 24 July 2024

What is going on over at ASSAP?


 Romer resigns!

Unfortunate events are occurring at the Association for the Scientific Study of Anomalous Phenomena (ASSAP).  The chair, Christian Jensen Romer (known as CJ), has resigned, along with the treasurer, Dr Becky Smith, plus a number of executive committee members.  Becky remains as treasurer on paper to satisfy legal requirements and to hand over to her successor, when appointed, in an orderly manner.  Meanwhile, the organisation ties itself in knots as factions snipe at each other on ASSAP’s Facebook page – a forum open to non-members as well as members.  As a member myself I have naturally followed events with interest.

The circumstances of this rift were initially murky.  Gradually it transpired that a faction of five individuals on the executive, pretentiously calling themselves ‘The Fellowship’ (a soubriquet they seemed a little embarrassed by once it had been made public), set up a private Messenger group bypassing ASSAP’s three directors: the chair, the treasurer and the secretary (Claire Davy).  On the face of it the problem seemed to be a simple oversight in informing the Charity Commission of a change to the Articles of Association, something that, while awkward, could surely be easily rectified.

 

Articles of Association confusion

What was the nature of this oversight?  An email was circulated to members on 3 July by Dr Hugh Pincott, ASSAP vice-president and company secretary (who has not otherwise been involved in the situation).  This contained a motion to be put to an EGM to be held on 25 July: ‘That the illegal Articles of Association agreed in 2010 be rescinded, and replaced by the previous ones of 2007. The latter are agreed to be valid by the Charity Commission and deemed by it to be our governing document.’

His explanatory notes amplify how this state of affairs had come about.  Essentially, ASSAP’s original 1981 Articles of Association were updated in 2007, then further updated in 2010 and passed by the membership at that year’s AGM.  But one change was that ASSAP should have only three directors – chair, secretary and treasurer.  The Charity Commission had stated that all trustees are directors, and an organisation should not have only three.  The 2007 version allowed all trustees to be directors.

The EGM motion over Pincott’s name therefore invited members to discard the 2010 Articles, which would not be approved by the Commission, thereby reinstating the 2007 ones.  Further, it would ‘protect our present and future Directors (doubtless acting through ignorance of the Law) from criminal prosecution by the Commission and Companies House.’  Such a proposal is wise, looking at past history.

No doubt if the 2010 Articles had been sent to the Charity Commission this problem would have been swiftly pointed out, but they were not, through an oversight of the then chair (not CJ) and secretary.  So not knowing of this update, the Charity Commission assumed the 2007 Articles were in operation, while the ASSAP executive assumed the 2010 version was valid.  Once this anomalous situation had become apparent, realisation dawned that something needed to be done.  Consequently, CJ spent hours on the phone to the Charity Commission to check that the 2010 articles complied with the law and were valid.

 

The Fellowship rings in

Unfortunately a subset of executive members managed to blow up an administrative problem into chaos.  Whether rightly or wrongly, the three directors CJ, Becky and (apparently) Claire understood The Fellowship intended to remove them, using the confusion over the Articles as ammunition, even though none of the three had been involved in the 2010 error.  This involved The Fellowship contacting the Charity Commission direct, without the chair’s knowledge, rather than through the official organisational channel, in order to confirm the accuracy of CJ’s statements.  The result was seen as circumventing and undermining the directors.  This was what led to CJ and Becky’s resignation, followed by several other members of the 13-strong executive (CJ’s announcement on Facebook of his departure has since been deleted).  The major responsibility for sorting out the mess has fallen to Claire.

 

Parsons speaks

Naturally once the news of CJ’s departure broke there was alarm and despondency among the members, and a great deal of criticism was levelled at The Fellowship.  Initially there was little appetite by the Fellows to put their side of the story, but first Bill Eyre placed a defence on Facebook, then Steve Parsons, followed by a formal statement signed by all five.  In his commentary, Parsons noted the difficult personal circumstances CJ and Becky faced at the time the problem with the Articles came to light – Becky had suffered a bereavement in March, affecting both of them deeply – and while the fellows were conscious of the risk of losing Becky and CJ (presumably by undermining their authority, though Parsons is not specific on the point), it was felt action was required.

While nobody would disagree with that aim, the methods adopted are open to question.  Parsons asserts they were in fact doing CJ a favour by trying to ease his workload as they were obliged to ensure ASSAP’s good governance, and the extra pressure might have caused CJ to quit, something they were keen to avoid (even though in fact he was busy dealing with the Charity Commission to sort the problem out).  So they weren’t really going behind his back as conspirators, just being helpful by trying to clarify the situation prior to an executive meeting.  Parsons stresses there was no secrecy, but it’s hard to see quite how this process was transparent with the chair and treasurer excluded, plus other executive members missing.  He makes no reference to the secretary, who should have been included in such discussions, as she made clear in a Facebook comment.  There was in fact no legitimacy to The Fellowship’s actions.

And the name?  Group chats require a title according to Parsons, so The Fellowship was used off the cuff, with no deep meaning.  My understanding is the group was using Messenger, not WhatsApp as originally stated, and it isn’t necessary to give a Messenger group a name, so I don’t know what Parsons is referring to here.  He feels it was unfortunate this desire to help had the opposite effect of pushing CJ to resign, leading to hostility towards The Fellowship.  And finally, he says, if the entire executive were to resign, as has been mooted by some members, then ASSAP would cease to function.  That is true if they were not replaced, but there may be members willing to take on the challenge, and be team players.

 

The Fellowship puts its side

There followed a ‘Statement of facts relating to the governance of ASSAP’, dated 15 July, signed by the gang of five and sent to members, which at least finally made clear all the names of those involved.  This picked up many of the points in the statements released by Eyre and Parsons on Facebook.  Noting they now formed the majority of those left on the executive (five out of eight), the rest having resigned, they put forward their version ‘to clarify events.’  They refer to statements made by CJ at executive meetings during 2024 about governance which concerned the signatories and of which they claimed to have been previously unaware.  A group held ‘offline’ discussions (i.e. not in meetings of the executive) ‘to identify their concerns and consider how these could be raised with C J without causing upset or offence or seeming to make any false accusations.’

They could have said to CJ they were worried about the issues he had highlighted and suggested they seek to resolve them collectively.  I’m sure he would not have been upset or offended, quite the contrary.  Yet the Fellows refer to ‘accusations’ because bizarrely ‘we had gained the impression that CJ was perhaps ‘inventing’ rules as he went along and thought that he had produced a ‘new version of the A of A [Articles of Association]’.  One can see why CJ might have been offended by the suggestion, but they could have been put right easily enough had they only asked.  Reading the Articles would have helped comprehension.  Either CJ was spectacularly opaque in his presentation or the clique was being disingenuous.

What to do?   Well, they continue, they were going to talk to CJ, but before they had a chance, they say Stu Neville informed him of these secret discussions, at which point CJ resigned, making allegations that there was a ‘secretive coup to overthrow him.’  It should be noted that Neville, who resigned from the executive when the scandal broke, was said by CJ not to be the source, rather he was told by three separate individuals, one of whom had signed this very statement – it sounds as though members of The Fellowship were not being candid with each other.  But they claim there was no coup, secret or otherwise, so CJ was wrong.  As ‘concerned trustees’ they were merely trying to work out the correct rules, adding it is not unusual for subsets of executive members to discuss items such as events or training privately before bringing them to the attention of the full executive.

All blown out of proportion then.  But these constitutional matters are more fundamental than training or events, which would be handled by the executive member responsible before discussion by the full executive.  Furthermore, CJ had brought these items to their attention, so it seemed odd to exclude both him and the secretary from the Messenger chat when CJ was operating normally despite Becky’s bereavement, and Claire would have been perfectly able to contribute.  Yet the directors were conspicuous by their absence from the group, despite the key role they would need to play in rectifying past mistakes.

 

The regrettable misunderstandings

The Fellowship claim they acted with the best of intentions, and CJ’s resignation arose from two misunderstandings, one on either side.  The first was their assumption that the 2010 Articles had been ‘the work of CJ,’ whereas they had been the responsibility of a previous chair.  They were told this by CJ after he resigned, and they say that had they known beforehand, there would have been no need to have the ‘offline’ conversation.  They do not concede that this is what you get when you cut a key player out of the loop and act on incomplete information.  The second was CJ’s assumption that there was a plot to unseat him and seize the leadership of ASSAP.  It was never contemplated ‘owing to it being an onerous, time consuming, yet unpaid, role.’

A fair assessment, yet they still undermined the chair, and presumably the notion didn’t pop into CJ’s head from nowhere, unless The Fellowship want to add a charge of paranoia.  They conclude that the business could have been avoided by having an executive meeting before CJ resigned, though they could easily have requested one by approaching the secretary.  They maintain that ‘CJ’s decision to become petulant, resign and involve the whole of the ASSAP membership in these matters has undoubtedly brought ASSAP into disrepute,’ a sentiment a contributor on Facebook characterised as a textbook example of gaslighting.

The Fellowship said they had initially refrained from commenting to avoid further argument, but had no choice because CJ’s ‘distorted account’ had resulted in ‘malicious accusations’ against The Fellowship, though actually their silence had stoked annoyance as it looked as though they had no adequate response.  When CJ resigned there was an outpouring of affection for him on the Facebook page, with many positive comments about his various activities for ASSAP, and a marked feeling he had been hard done by, but criticisms were measured, not malicious.

While they thought CJ was a good researcher and speaker, The Fellowship believed ‘his petulant nature and periodic outbursts when dealing with other members of the Executive does make us doubt his suitability for the Chairman’s role.’  They had previously said they had no plans to oust him and couldn’t think who else might take on this ‘onerous, time-consuming’ position anyway, now he is unsuitable for the job.  The thought processes appear confused.  An indignant Hayley Stevens took exception to the repeated use of petulant and wrote a blog post titled ‘ASSAP Exec. Loses Plot, Call (sic) CJ Romer “Petulant”’.

 

Romer bites back

Not only Hayley Stevens took exception.  The Fellows’ self-justification evoked an email to members from the man himself, a clearly annoyed CJ setting out his ‘final statement’ following his earlier Facebook interventions.  Beginning by highlighting the lack of communication leading to this outcome, he exonerates Neville from the charge of having dobbed The Fellowship to him.  He also mentions in passing an allegation by The Fellowship that he had changed passwords when they had not been changed, indicating a worrying lack of competence on their part.  He alludes to complaints made about a talk he had given, though no details have been aired.  Naturally he is vexed by the reference to petulance because naturally he sees his action as proportionate and considered.

He says he and Becky were planning to stand down at the 2024 AGM in October anyway, but wanted an orderly transition, a long way from what has happened.  Not only has he stepped down from the executive, he has left ASSAP, although finishing off some jobs.  Other outstanding business will fall to what remains of the executive, not least the Journal and magazine, currently being proofread.  Normally CJ and Becky would oversee production and dispatch, but he has passed the task on to the no doubt chuffed publications officer.

 

Next steps

The Fellowship contends CJ overreacted, but I would say his response has been entirely reasonable.  I’m sure I would have felt much the same had I discovered a group of executive members were going behind my back and doubting what I was saying, however they dressed it up.  I’ve known him thirty years, and whatever the merits of the Fellowship’s case he is an honourable, hardworking, highly intelligent individual who has given a great deal of service to ASSAP over many years, as chair, editor of its publications, talk organiser and presenter, as well as the administration that goes with committee work.  Looked at objectively, it is hard to disagree he has been shabbily treated, even if one charitably characterises the actions of The Fellowship as merely inept.

The Fellowship sign off their 15 July statement by acknowledging that several executive members had resigned because of the stress (though there are other explanations), express the wish that the remaining ones will carry on trying to provide services, and welcome new members who decide to stand at the 2024 AGM in the autumn.  Whether the executive can carry on so severely understaffed for the next three months is debatable.  In particular, the resignations of executive members have created a great deal of work for the secretary.

Unsurprisingly there have been numerous calls to hold elections for all executive posts immediately, and if they are, The Fellowship will discover how convincing their arguments and justifications have been (the one Fellow who may feel he is safe is Steve Parsons, because he is so deeply embedded in the ASSAP training programme).  When the elections are held the membership will face hard choices, not least whether it wants individuals whose judgement has been so lacking to continue in positions of responsibility.  The EGM to be held on 25 July may present a way forward, and allow the Association to rebuild.  The Fellowship members will be a key aspect of the debate, I’m sure.

 

Acknowledgement: The image was generated at OpenArt AI, using the prompt ‘crisis in psychical research’.


Friday, 12 July 2024

A couple of coincidences


These are notes of a couple of coincidences I experienced in 2020 which have been sitting in my file ever since.  I offer them diffidently, on the assumption that some people will find them about as interesting as hearing someone else’s dream.  On the other hand, while they probably have no significance, they still leave me with a feeling they might point to something deeper I cannot quite put my finger on (the reason I noted them).

 

1 Cause Célèbre

On the evening of Friday 24 April 2020, I sat down with my wife to watch the 1987 Anglia Television adaptation of Terence Rattigan’s final play Cause Célèbre, starring Helen Mirren, Harry Andrews and David Morrissey as Alma Rattenbury, her husband Francis, and her young lover George Bowman respectively.  The play is based on the real-life murder at Bournemouth in 1935 of Alma’s elderly husband and the subsequent trial of Alma Rattenbury and George Stoner (presumably the name change to Bowman was because Stoner was still alive in 1987) at the Old Bailey.

While I was putting the DVD into the player I mentioned I was familiar with the case from a true crime volume, and said, disregarding spoilers, that the husband was attacked by the lover when Alma and her husband were walking along a suburban road and the young man jumped out from behind a hedge, bludgeoning him.  As we watched the programme it was clear this was not how the murder happened: George creeps into the downstairs bedroom of ‘Ratz’, as Alma calls her husband, and whacks him several times with a mallet, cracking his skull.  Clearly, I had been confusing it with another case, but a search the following morning did not throw up what it was.

A few hours later I was reading the Daily Telegraph’s Saturday review section and turned to Simon Heffer’s ‘Hinterland’ column.  He writes about aspects of British culture and generally has something interesting to say.  To my surprise his subject was a 1934 novel by F Tennyson Jesse, A Pin to See the Peepshow, a fictionalised retelling of the Thompson/Bywaters murder case at Ilford in 1922.  Although Heffer does not refer to the manner of the murder, the mention of Thompson was enough to remind me this was the case I had had in mind the previous evening.  Edith Thompson had an affair with the lodger, Frederick Bywaters.  One night, while Edith and her husband Percy were walking home, Frederick jumped out from some bushes and stabbed Percy several times, fatally injuring him.

There were similarities in the Thompson and Rattenbury cases: an affair between a married woman and a younger man leading to violence against the husband, though whereas in the latter Alma was acquitted (shortly afterwards committing suicide) and George’s capital sentence was commuted to a prison term, both Edith and Frederick were hanged.  This was clearly a miscarriage of justice as there was no evidence Edith was complicit in the death of her husband.  Perhaps the more lenient judicial outcome for Alma and George 13 years later – the court of public opinion was another matter – was influenced by the earlier verdict.  I had wrongly recalled that Percy Thompson was bludgeoned, as Francis Rattenbury was, because he was stabbed; I had clearly conflated the two murders.

This was a minor coincidence to be sure, but it seemed odd to have the reference I had been seeking fall into my lap with no effort after having failed to track it down a mere couple of hours before.  They are both fairly well-known true-crime cases of course, but Heffer ranges widely over British culture, and there were many topics he could have addressed other than A Pin to See the Peepshow.  However, another echo on Sunday 26 April, when I heard about a multiple stabbing in Ilford, indicated the need for caution when assessing events with so many potential associations.

Then to my surprise the following month the Rattenbury murder popped up again, with no effort on my part to seek it out.  The excellent Strange Histories blog (subtitled ‘A walk on the weird side of history’), which I follow, published a lengthy post on 25 May 2020 titled ‘A Moment of Madness: Murder at the Villa Madeira’.  This recounted the background, murder and aftermath in some detail, highlighting the complexities of the confessions which raise doubts over who actually killed Francis Rattenbury.  A comment remarking it would make a good film elicited the reply that Cause Célèbre was based on the case.  This is the sort of story Strange Histories would cover so its inclusion was not surprising, but it felt noteworthy coming so shortly after what was already a coincidence relating to the Rattenbury case.

But it was not the last time it crossed my horizon during those weeks.  On 1 July I received an email from a Sean O’Connor about a particular topic he was working on with which he thought I could assist (it became the 2022 book The Haunting of Borley Rectory).  Not knowing the name, I looked him up and discovered he was the author of the 2019 non-fiction book The Fatal Passion of Alma Rattenbury, which discusses the Edith Thompson trial.  By now of course I was picking up on any mention of these cases, whereas at one time they would perhaps have passed by little noticed (leaving aside my general interest in true crime), but it still seems strange to come across so many references over so short a period.

 

2 ESP in Life and Lab

If anything, this was odder.  I was reading Louisa E Rhine’s 1967 ESP in Life and Lab:Tracing Hidden Channels, a book mixing anecdotal evidence sent by members of the public and the results of laboratory research into psi processes.  One of the anecdotes (pp. 192-4) was about a dream a woman had had.  In it she came upon a house, inside which she could see a room set up for what looked like a wedding breakfast, although there were no people around.  A few weeks later she and her husband were invited to a meal to celebrate his having achieved 25 years with his company (something neither had realised was imminent until he was told).

The meal took place at a new inn they had never been to before.  Although reluctant to go, it proved to be a very enjoyable lunch.  The writer said they married during the Depression and did not have much of a celebration, so this felt more like her wedding than the real one had.  When they entered the dining room, she had a feeling she had been in it before, and after she returned home she realised the room was the one in her dream though reversed, as in the dream she was looking in from the outside, hence she had not immediately recognised it.

Now, quite often dates are not given in these accounts; the year is mentioned, sometimes the month, but precise dates are infrequent, probably a function of the delay between having the experience and writing the report.  In this case, however, the precise date is supplied.  The date of the dream, which the dreamer took to represent a room where a wedding was to take place, was 7 March 1953.  That was the very day my parents married in south London.  There is no doubt about the date of the dream because the dreamer wrote her account straight away.

This was one of many reports in the extensive Rhine collection that could have been used to illustrate the point being made, and one of the few in the book with a precise date.  To then find the reference to a wedding has a date which tallies with an event of personal significance (albeit occurring before my time!) seems remarkable.  There would have been few things linking a middle-class couple in Virginia and a working-class couple in Camberwell, but here a dream provided a connection only appreciated 67 years later.  I should add the reason I am sure of the date of my parents’ wedding is because I was born on their wedding anniversary.

 

I have had a couple of other experiences, as recounted in the Autumn/Winter 1996 issue of However Improbable, the magazine of the long-gone Anglia Paranormal Research Group.  In the first of these, when I was a student, I was hitchhiking with a girlfriend to Greece and we met some college acquaintances, also hitch-hiking, on a minor road somewhere in Yugoslavia (also long gone).  In the second, while on a family holiday from Norfolk, we bumped into my young daughter’s best friend from home in Carlisle railway station.

These are incidents in life that seem to have no great meaning (though I was happy to have my idle curiosity about English domestic murder satisfied in such an easy fashion by Mr Heffer) but they catch our attention.  Similar anecdotes can be told by many people, the sort of thing that makes one wonder about the interconnectedness of life no explanations couched in terms of the law of large numbers can quite satisfy.

 


Wednesday, 19 June 2024

The Ghostly Gift of Miss Constance Couper, by Sean Lang


Sean Lang’s latest play, acted with an all-women cast by Combined Actors of Cambridge, was produced at Cambridge’s ADC Theatre from the 16th to 20th April 2024.  The Ghostly Gift of Miss Constance Couper is very loosely inspired by Charlotte Moberly (1846-1937), principal of St Hugh’s College, Oxford, and Eleanor Jourdain (1863-1924), who became her vice-principal and eventually succeeded her.  While visiting Versailles in August 1901 they claimed to have been transported back to the late eighteenth century, as recounted in their book An Adventure, first published in 1911 and appearing in five editions until 1955.  They used the pseudonyms Elizabeth Morison and Frances Lamont, and the fourth edition, published in 1931, while Moberly was alive, was the first to include the authors’ real names.

Lang, an Oxford graduate, was, until his recent retirement, Senior Lecturer in history at Anglia Ruskin University and – full disclosure – the internal examiner when I took a PhD at ARU.  He weaves together three time-lines: the horrors of the French Revolution, in particular its effect on Marie Antoinette; the academics Misses Annie Martindale and Constance Couper at Oxford, including their holiday visit to Versailles, after which Miss Martindale writes a book detailing an alleged time-slip; and a couple of young women in 1968 sharing the house in which Martindale and Couper had lived together.

However, the events recounted by Miss Martindale are faked, the book instigated by Miss Couper as part of a nefarious plot to discredit her colleague, force her retirement, and assume her position as principal of St Hugh’s.  A scene shows Miss Martindale offering the job as her deputy to Miss Couper, who delightedly accepts, then proposing they share Miss Martindale’s house close to the college, which she owns.  Miss Couper accepts Miss Martindale’s generosity and uses it to her advantage.

After their holiday, Miss Couper suggests they use the visit to Versailles and the people they had seen while walking around to produce a narrative describing how they were transported back to the eighteenth century.  They would both write accounts, containing minor discrepancies to demonstrate they had been written independently but agreeing on all important points.  Initially, Miss Couper says they should do this as a private exercise for their own entertainment, a jeu d’esprit, and Miss Martindale enthusiastically agrees.

Later, Miss Couper encourages the naive Miss Martindale to publish the account, knowing the result would be to make her look credulous, and lose the support of the college fellows in the ensuing controversy.  With Miss Martindale eased out, Miss Couper, despite her weaknesses as an academic, would be well situated to replace her.  The plan appears to be on the point of working when Miss Martindale says she wishes to step down. 

Unfortunately for Miss Couper, the mild Miss Martindale then baulks at the prospect of resignation, and in a riverside confrontation declares that not only does she have no intention of standing down but, having seen through Miss Couper’s strategy, intends to force her out instead, possessing proof Miss Couper had played a full part in the planning and execution of the book.  However, if finesse cannot work, force can, and Miss Couper pushes her colleague into the river, the death allowing Miss Couper to have the top job after all.

Miss Couper tries to recruit an able young lecturer, Miss Ada Smart, to her side by dangling a fellowship, and Miss Smart become Miss Couper’s vice-principal.  Later, disenchanted by Miss Smart, Miss Couper tells her that she plans to force her out.  However, during the inquest Miss Couper stated she had been in the house at the time Miss Martindale drowned, but Miss Smart, who had accompanied Miss Martindale to the river for a walk before leaving her to attend a suffragette meeting, had seen Miss Couper close by.

Belatedly going over the inquest documents, Miss Smart compiles enough circumstantial evidence to show the death might not have been an accident, the mere hint of which would cause a scandal for Miss Couper.  The price of Miss Smart’s silence?  Miss Couper’s resignation, enabling Miss Smart to take over as principal.  To this Miss Couper agrees (one might think she would attempt to brazen it out), but she continues to live close by in the house, dying there an embittered old woman.

The second time period follows Marie Antoinette at Versailles as the French Revolution begins and gradually the violence escalates, until not only does it destroy the royal family but is killing even those who had supported it.  The third period is1968.  Sheila Smart, Ada’s great-niece and a student at St Hugh’s, moves in and is joined by fellow student Perdi Warrender.  Sheila has been given the accommodation rent free, and assumes this was thanks to her great-aunt.  Sheila is a buttoned-up provincial intent on her studies while Perdi is a cosmopolitan hedonist, but despite their initial friction a friendship grows between them, and they find they have more in common than they initially realised.

Then mysterious, and increasingly scary, events start to happen and it becomes clear the house is haunted.  The haunting escalates and the students realise there is an intelligence behind it.  Perdi does some digging in the archive and learns it was not Sheila’s great-aunt who had been her benefactor.  Rather, Miss Couper had willed the house to the college on the understanding that should any descendants of Ada Smart ever come to the college to study, they would be given rooms there free of charge.

The reason for her largesse towards a relative of the person who had destroyed her career was because it would give her an opportunity to be revenged on Miss Smart by proxy.  As Sheila is a diabetic, this can be achieved by hiding her insulin syringe, leading to diabetic coma.  At the climax, with Perdi shut out of the house by the paranormal force and Sheila close to unconsciousness, the full-form apparition of Miss Couper appears and menaces her.  She is saved by Miss Smart who appears and by an act of will forces Miss Couper back (the ghostliness of each signalled by the wearing of veils covering their faces).  Perdi is able to enter and help Sheila administer her insulin, saving her and thwarting Miss Couper.

In his programme notes Lang asks who would have been the ghosts in 1901 if Moberly and Jourdain had really gone back in time.  It would not have been those in the eighteenth century ‘now’, rather the visitors from its future.  But even with their ghostly presence Lang notes the time-slip is not scary (though to be fair that was not Moberly and Jourdain’s intention) and says he wanted his play to be scary, hence why he added the 1968 thread.  He was able to introduce a more conventional kind of ghost, a familiar horror type as seen for example in The Woman in Black, to menace the living.  But the aim was not merely to provide a frisson for the audience, a theme was how each of the three periods featured emancipation of some kind, but with limited gains for women.

The identification of Miss Martindale with Charlotte Moberly and Miss Couper with Eleanor Jourdain is so close that the uninformed viewer would be forgiven for thinking Lang is presenting a scenario close to the reality.  He is of course free to create any kind of play he likes based on historical events, but his distorted treatment of Moberly and Jourdain, including murder, is actually distasteful.  Moberly became the first principal of St Hugh’s College, Oxford, in 1886.  Jourdain was her deputy and succeeded her as principal in 1915, remaining so until her death.  So, while the play has Martindale/Moberly dying violently while in post, easing the way for Couper/Jourdain, actually Moberly outlived Jourdain.  Nor was Jourdain ousted by a younger academic, leading her to ‘haunt’ the college in her old age, rather she retained the position until her death.  Lang has used an incident in Jourdain’s career when she ill-advisedly attempted to dismiss a colleague, which would have likely resulted in her resignation, but she died of natural causes first.  Most obviously, while the authors used pseudonyms, from the first edition it was clear that An Adventure was a joint effort, not the product of a single pen.

Lang paints Martindale as weak and manipulated by Couper, who is also able to use undue influence on the college fellows, until Martindale stands up to her, with fatal consequences.  But there is no indication the relationship between Moberly and Jourdain became toxic, and it is implausible that someone so weak-willed would have managed to achieve such a senior level in an Oxford college.  Nor is it likely the book was a cynical hoax, the authors knowing the events it depicts were fictional.  The content of An Adventure is heavily contested, but the considerable amount of discussion it has generated since 1911 invariably starts with the assumption they were sincere, even if mistaken.  By playing fast and loose with the facts, Lang has done their memory a disservice.